Black Holes and Electromagnetism

Black Holes and Electromagnetism

Boris V. Gudiksen & Bjørn Østman

Abstract:

Contents

Black Hole Electrodynamics

Black hole electrodynamics is the theory of electrodynamics outside a black hole. This is evident since we cannot gain information about anything inside the event horizon (i.e. tex2html_wrap_inline266 ).
Black hole electrodynamics can be very trivial if you consider just a black hole described by the three usual parameters: mass, electric charge and angular momentum. Initially simplifying the case by disregarding rotation, we simply get the well known solution of a point charge. This is of course not physically very interesting, since it seems highly unlikely that any black hole (or any celestial body) should not be rotating. Adding rotation then we have to use the Kerr metric with the change that charge is present. This is the Kerr-Newmann geometry where

equation51 (1)

A rotating charged black hole creates a magnetic field around the hole because the inertial frame is dragged around the hole. Far from the black hole at infinity the black hole electric field is that of a point charge, and the magnetic field is a dipole with magnetic moment tex2html_wrap_inline268 .

However, black holes do not even have charges. The ratio of charge to mass, Q/M, cannot exceed tex2html_wrap_inline270 because even charges would be repelled from the hole, and different charges would neutralize the charge of the hole. So we are forced to consider the elctrodynamic fields located in the environment outside the black hole.

The domain of a black hole can be separated into three regions (see fig. 1).

1)
The rotating black hole itself and the area near it.
2)
The accretion disk (a region of force-free fields).
3)
An acceleration region outside the plasma.

The magnetic field is frozen into the plasma (flux-freezing) when the conductivity is so high that the electric field in the reference frame comoving with the plasma vanishes. Then we have that the electric and magnetic fields are perpendicular:

  equation64 (2)

and that the field is force-free:

  equation68 (3)

where tex2html_wrap_inline272 is the electric charge density. If the electrodynamic forces dominate over the inertial and gravitational forces, then electric fields and currents moving with the plasma are parallel to the magnetic field-lines. This condition is violated at the event horizon. In the acceleration region (zone 3 in fig. 1) both equation 2 and 3 is violated. In this region the magnetic field of the plasma in region 2 is small enough for inertial forces to dominate.
Conditions 2 and 3 may not hold near the event horizon, and deviations from these could be important for some physical processes happening there.


Figure 1: Accretion onto a black hole. The dotted line is an example of an electric current line.

Accretion Disks

Disk accretion can occur onto supermassive black holes at the center of galaxies and in binary systems where one of the bodies is a black hole (not necessarily supermassive) and the other (star) has exceeded its critical Roche equipotential lobe. One example of this is Cyg X-1 with a 33 tex2html_wrap_inline344 star losing material to the 16 tex2html_wrap_inline344 black hole. Other good candidates are LMC X-3 and A0620-00.
The accretion disk of a rotating black hole is by the black hole driven into the equatorial plane of the rotation. This is the Bardeen-Petterson effect (see fig. 2). It is not until small r < 100M that the disk is equatorial. The force on the disk is gravitational, gravitomagnetic forces (field-line stretching and recombination) and viscosity. At about r = 2 to 20M the plasma in the disk either falls into the black hole, or is somehow ejected in either one or two jets aligned with the rotation axis of the black hole (and the disk).


Figure 2: Bardeen-Petterson effect.

Black Hole Magnetosphere

The processes taking place in the magnetosphere of a black hole is so complex that a full theory has not been developed to describe it. However, some qualitative features can be deduced.
In the accretion disk around a supermassive black hole gravitational energy is converted into kinetic, thermal and magnetic energy. The thermal energy ensures that the gas in the disk is highly ionized. The gas is therefore turned into plasma, in which perfect MHD exists. In other words, flux-freezing is maintained in the plasma of the accretion disk. This is true for the plasma not too close to the event horizon, where magnetic field lines is separated from the plasma as it is drawn into the black hole. Then the magnetic field lines might attach themselves to the surface of the black hole, or they may be pushed away from the hole and back into the disk.


Figure 3: The inner region of a black hole. The lines penetrating the accretion disk (which by no means is as thin as shown here; see fig. 1) are magnetic field-lines. Notice the surface (curled A) and the boundary (curled C).

Consider figure 3. The closed curve C = tex2html_wrap_inline354 A lies in the accretion disk far from the black hole, where the flux is frozen into the plasma. We look at it from the point of view of a fiducial observer, far from the black hole and the disk. Faraday's law applied to the surface and the boundary gives us

  equation194 (4)

Using the condition that the field is frozen to the plasma at the boundary

equation205 (5)

where v is the velocity of the plasma as measured by the observer far from the black hole, equation 4 becomes

equation212 (6)

The RHS is the rate with which flux is carried in towards the black hole through the boundary, and the LHS is the flux change per time interval through the surface. It is now obvious that the magnetic flux must be conserved in time seen from the distant observer.
This is an important conclusion. Now the magnetic field-lines near the black hole can be described: If some irregularity in the field-lines should happen near the horizon, it will be smeared out with the local velocity of light. Thus the magnetic field near the horizon will be very clean and uniform, not depending on the state of the magnetic field in the plasma, which is likely to be very chaotic and disordered. Irregularities in the field near the event horizon posed by the field in the disk will be sorted out in a time

equation223

Flux Freezing

Flux freezing is an interesting physical phenomenon which, as we have already mentioned, is present in connection with an accretion disc. This is a known effect in plasma physics, but perhaps unknown to most physicists. It comes out of well known electrodynamic laws. Flux freezing is simply that the magnetic flux through a contour moving with the fluid is constant. Since this holds for all magnetic field strengths and all kinds of velocity fields, the plasma is able to amplify or damp the magnetic field by movement. We can deduce this by following a contour moving with the plasma. At a time t, the countour is denoted by C at the time t+ dt the contour has moved the distance phi_eq_const and been changed to C' (see figure). Let now S_c be an element of area on any surface bounded by C, and S_c' an element of area on any surface bounded by C'. The area bounded by a little element ds on the countour C, a little elment ds' on C' and the element phi_eq_const is    . Since Maxwell's 2'nd equation on integral form gives us:

eq_1

we have that the total flux through the closed surface bounded by C and C' at t+dt is given by:

eq_2

And then the change in flux from t to t+dt is:

eqn_3

By using Stoke's theorem and

           eqn_4 
we have:

eq_5

In the last step we used a vector-relation. So now we se that the flux through a contour moving with the fluid is constant. Since this holds for all B and all kinds of velocity fields the plasma is able to amplify or damp a magnetic field. This is called dynamo effect.

img

Disc Field Lines

From all of this we get that ionized gas falling towards a rotating black hole will start to rotate around it and carry the poloidal field lines with it. After many rotations the field has been wound up tightly and the magnetic field has been amplified many times. This effect is so powerful that the toroidal field in the disc will be many times stronger than the poloidal field. The disc is off course not rotating as a rigid body. The rotation is differential, and there is turbulence, and other effects that make it behave chaotically on small scale. Apart from the differential rotation, the overall picture will remain the same.
In this project we have vizualized a snapshot (no time evolution) of a rotating disc which is chaotic on small scales.
Back to main page - To the exhibitions - Top of document

Boris Gudiksen & Bjørn Østman
18.58.00 Sun june 16 1996